Marketing Information

How Price Gouging Can Hurt Your Business


"Price gouging" is an emotional, inflammatory term. Everyone is against it, but only buyers, angry over excessive profit-taking, proclaim it. As a seller, how can you reap the profit rewards you deserve without being accused of price gouging?

From a marketer's perspective, attaching a price tag to a product or service is always an agonizing experience. What is the right price? This question is hotly debated in meeting rooms around the world every day. The search for the perfect price may be the Holy Grail of marketing.

Pricing is like sunblock. No matter how you decide to apply it, the question always lingers; how much is enough? How can you avoid leaving money on the table without being burned by claims of price gouging?

While everyone certainly wants win-win relationships, the buyer and seller are adversaries where pricing is concerned. The seller wants to get the most money possible for their offering, because each additional dollar gained is pure profit. From the buyer's perspective, less is better and free is best.

The List Price Obstacle

Most claims of price gouging are based on comparisons of asking price to published list price. From the buyer's perspective, list price is the ceiling, the most they should have to pay for a seller's offering. More importantly, list price becomes the basis from which discounts are taken.

The idea of establishing a list price for a product is actually a fairly new invention. As recent as the middle Middle agesAges, prices were based on perceived ability to pay versus being tied to some intrinsic worth of the product itself. For example, when a nobleman was purchasing a commodity such as food, they would routinely pay several multiples over what a peasant farmer would pay for the same product. Why? Because they could. The seller would have no trouble asking the nobleman for the higher price, and the nobleman would have no problem paying. In those days, gouging only referred to activities having to do with battles and body parts.

For most of us, we believe prices can only go down from list price. When buying a car, for example, nobody expects to pay "sticker". In fact, many car buyers believe that list price shouldn't be the basis of pricing discussions at all. Instead, they focus on working from the dealer's invoice price. How shocked these same buyers are when they're asked to pay over sticker! This has happened when anticipation for a new model creates high demand though the product is in short supply. Examples include the original releases of the Mazda Miata, Dodge Viper, Nissan Xterra, the reintroduced Volkswagen Beetle, and the 2005 Mustang.

When sellers ask for more than list price, buyers deem it "unfair", "outrageous" and -- of course --price gouging. Now it's time to play the blame game. We can blame manufacturing for not producing enough vehicles to meet demand. We can blame marketing for creating too much interest in a product they couldn't supply. We can blame the greedy capitalists who are exploiting the citizens. Nobody seems to think to blame the use of a list price.

List prices are some of the best fiction ever written.

Should We Sell Over List?

Some routinely call the selling of a product at more than list price "gouging," and consider it unethical and even immoral.

Buyers feel gouged when it appears that sellers are taking advantage of the buyer's condition with a commodity product. I'll loosely define commodity as any product or service that has a fairly consistent price in most selling environments. When the buyer sees an inflated price for the commodity and has no other competitive alternatives due to the situation they're in, the buyer feels gouged.

For example, I would expect a hot dog and a Coke at most locations to be 4 or 5 US dollars. When I was watching the Atlanta Braves play baseball at Turner Field and got hungry, the hot dog and Coke I found cost closer to $10. To find any food that I considered reasonably priced, I would have to leave the stadium environment. I felt gouged.

As a boater, I routinely pay 30-40% more at the dock for a gallon of gas than I would when I take my car to the pumps. Same gas, different environment. I feel gouged.

Price gouging occurs when no alternatives are available for purchase. In our free market society, that rarely happens. When it does, we need to be especially careful. Where there is demand, there is usually -- but not always -- competition.

A Controversial Solution

An opportunistic sales force that I once worked with faced a pricing dilemma. Buyers in this industry routinely expected a 15-20% discount, making it nearly impossible to hold list price. The solution came to be known as "New York Pricing" -- invented by the New York district office -- which simply involved marking up list price by 15% before presenting it to the prospective buyer. After ardent negotiations, the buyer might receive their 15-20% discount, resulting in a sale at or near list price for company. Because headquarters couldn't come up with a better solution, "New York Pricing" was widely practiced by the sales team although not officially endorsed by management.

Gouging is in the Eye of the Beholder

While we might like the market to set the price, we can't all engage in an auction environment. At some point during a buyer-seller interaction, the seller is going to offer a price. This is perceived by the buyer as list price, and we expect to go down from there.

Price gouging is not about charging more than list price. It's about the seller taking advantage of the environment to require people to pay more than the offering is worth. Selling over list price is fine if the market is willing to bid up the price despite the presence of alternatives. That's what happens with hot new cars. If the buyer believes they are getting value well in excess of the list price, both parties can feel good about the transaction.

© 2005 Paul Johnson. All rights reserved.

Note: This article is available for reprint at no charge. We only ask that you include our copyright notice in your reprint, along with the About the Author (byline) information we provide at the end of the article.

Paul Johnson of Panache and Systems LLC consults and speaks on business strategy for systematically boosting sales performance using Shortcuts to Yes?. Check out more salesforce development tips at http://panache-yes.com/tips.html Call Paul direct in Atlanta, Georgia, USA at (770) 271-7719.


MORE RESOURCES:

Marketing Week

Coca-Cola to Boost Marketing Efforts
Wall Street Journal
The Atlanta-based beverage maker said the new productivity targets, scheduled to be completed by the end of 2015, include taking costs out of the supply chain and more effective marketing. On Tuesday, Coke also reported a 71% drop in fourth-quarter ...
Coca-Cola Reinvests in MarketingAdAge.com
Coca-Cola to reinvest productivity savings into brand building marketingMarketing Week
Coke Earnings: Profits Up, But Sales DownThe Beverage Network
Food Product Design
all 373 news articles »


Bennett Recognized as an International Top Sales and Marketing Mind
MarketWatch (press release)
7, 2012 /PRNewswire via COMTEX/ -- White Lodging Services is pleased to announce Michael Bennett, vice president eCommerce and communications, has been named to the list of the 2011 Hospitality Sales & Marketing Association International (HSMAI) Top 25 ...

and more »


Marketing Pilgrim

5 Marketing Tips from the Social Commerce Summit
Marketing Pilgrim
Here's my pick for the top 5 pieces of marketing advice culled from lists put together by Business Insider. Search is extremely important to us. Google will have its way and we will have to focus on Google+. We launched our presence on Google+ ...

and more »


Content Marketing Institute, ON24 Announce Virtual Communication Excellence ...
MarketWatch (press release)
SAN FRANCISCO, CA, Feb 07, 2012 (MARKETWIRE via COMTEX) -- Recognizing the increasing importance of the virtual distribution of content in organizations today, the Content Marketing Institute (CMI) and ON24 are recognizing excellence in virtual ...

and more »


Adweek

Players Who Boosted Their Marketing Value in Sunday's Super Bowl
Adweek
By David Schwab, Octagon First Call The New York Giants won Sunday's Super Bowl, but which individual players scored in the marketing playbook? Let's look at five who did themselves proud. • Eli Manning. Eli is now on a short list of two-time Super ...
Eli Manning's Marketability Expected To SoarSportsBusiness Daily (subscription)
Eli Manning's second Super Bowl ring means soaring marketability, experts sayThe Star-Ledger - NJ.com

all 23,107 news articles »


Experian Marketing Services Appoints Marshall Stanton as Vice President of ...
MarketWatch (press release)
7, 2012 /PRNewswire via COMTEX/ -- Experian Marketing Services, a leading provider of data, analytics and marketing technologies that help organizations target and engage their customers more effectively across both traditional and digital media, ...

and more »


Manufacturers Can Now Market Directly to Product Specifiers for 1000s of New ...
MarketWatch (press release)
BidClerk -- the widely recognized leader in providing construction project data and marketing tools to manufacturers, contractors, and distributors -- today announced that is has once again redefined the landscape of construction information with the ...

and more »


B2B Marketing Leader, Televerde, Executive to Judge National Business Awards ...
San Francisco Chronicle (press release)
As a testament to Televerde's growing position as a B2B marketing leader, the company's Senior VP of Global Sales Donna Kent has been tapped to serve as a judge for the Stevie Awards for Sales & Customer Service, one of the most prestigious business ...

and more »


SCORR Marketing Marks Growth with New Branding
MarketWatch (press release)
KEARNEY, Neb., Feb 07, 2012 (BUSINESS WIRE) -- SCORR Marketing, a strategic marketing and public relations agency focused on market development through marketing communications, corporate identity/branding, media communications, advertising and ...

and more »


Northbound DGS Announces New ALTA Suite for Revenue & Engagement Marketing
Sacramento Bee
7, 2012 -- /PRNewswire/ -- Northbound DGS, a leading agency in Revenue and Engagement Marketing, today announced its new ALTA suite of integrated revenue generation solutions. Northbound's end-to-end solution is designed to let B2B Enterprises more ...

and more »

Google News

home | site map
© 2006